No. 031Marketing22 Nov 2026

The Cost of Dull: Peter Field on Attention, Trust and Cheap Reach

Justin Lebbon with Peter Field

40:35

Chapters

Effectiveness researcher Peter Field tells Justin why ad effectiveness is still "bumping along the bottom" — and how cheap, low-attention media, short-termism and dull creative are quietly destroying brand value.

Show notes

Effectiveness expert Peter Field joins Justin to diagnose why advertising effectiveness has been "bumping along the bottom" for years — and why the usual culprits (cheap media, short-termism, CFO cost-cutting, and dull creative) keep repeating the same mistakes. It's a sharp, data-grounded conversation about fixing the media problem before the creative one, the real value of attention over CPMs, and whether the rush into influencers is a strategy or a fashion.

  • Effectiveness hasn't turned the corner. Field says the decline that began in 2008 has flattened but shows no renaissance; blue-chip marketers are learning, the mass market isn't.
  • CFOs and CEOs are the problem, not marketers. Field argues the fight for balance between long and short is lost at the top, where leaders treat media as a cost game, not a value game.
  • The brand/performance "sweet spot" and Darwinism. Brands skewed 80/20 or worse toward performance eventually see the wheels come off — Adidas and Nike cited as costly cautionary tales.
  • Reach isn't reach without attention. Drawing on Karen Nelson-Field and Ehrenberg-Bass, Field says the legacy "reach" mantra must be updated: only attentive, quality reach builds mental availability.
  • Buy attentive CPMs, not cheap CPMs. Flip from lowest CPM to cost-per-thousand-seconds-of-attention and the hierarchy reverses — social looks expensive, TV looks like value.
  • The cost of dull. With Adam Morgan and IPA data, Field prices bottom-quartile "dull" advertising at roughly £10m extra per year for an average UK brand — many times more in the US.
  • Trust as an effectiveness driver. As fact-checking erodes on social, the medium shapes the message — ads surrounded by untruths underperform.
  • The influencer question. On Unilever and Coke shifting from broadcast to social-first: moving spend from social to influencers may be smart; moving it from proven TV to an unscalable, "wild west" creator world is a gamble he'd test far more gingerly.

Key takeaways

  • Effectiveness has plateaued at a low level since its decline began in 2008 — Field sees no genuine renaissance yet.
  • Short-termism is driven by CEOs and CFOs who treat media as a cost rather than an investment; smart marketers often know better but are overruled.
  • The Ehrenberg-Bass reach model must be updated with attention science: without attentive, quality reach you don't build mental availability.
  • Switching from cheap CPMs to attentive cost-per-second completely reverses the media value hierarchy — social gets expensive, TV looks like strong value.
  • 'Dull' (purely factual, performance-style) advertising carries a huge hidden cost — roughly £10m a year extra for an average UK brand, far more in the US.
  • Fix the media problem before the creative problem — great creative on a low-attention platform is wasted effort.
  • Shifting large budgets from TV to influencers is unproven and hard to scale with brand coherence; Field would test and learn, not announce a strategy pivot.
“Serving great creative on a shit platform is just a waste of everybody's time and effort. You need to fix the media problem before you can fix the creative problem.”
— Peter Field
“If you don't buy the right kind of reach, you are never gonna achieve mental availability because your attention levels are so low that you're not building long term memories.”
— Peter Field
Full transcript

Speaker 0 · 0:00

Smart marketers know that they need TV. Serving great creative on a shit platform is just a waste of everybody's time and effort. You need to fix the media problem before you can fix the creative problem.

Speaker 1 · 0:16

Peter, welcome. How are you doing?

Speaker 0 · 0:18

Thanks, Justin. Doing well. Thanks. Yep. No. All all good all good in The UK, and very interesting times too, which I'm sure we'll we'll chat about more. Something

Speaker 1 · 0:28

that I talk about a lot is the state of overall effectiveness. You know? How effective are advertisers today? And I know that you you track that and you have done for for a very long time. And since the sort of inception, if you like, of performance marketing, effectiveness has been declining. Right? But we've we've plateaued, so we could be getting better. So just quickly,

Speaker 0 · 0:48

how is the industry doing today from your... From that side of things? Well, I mean, I'm waiting to sort of update the tracker that I normally do, but I'm... We've been bumping along the bottom bottom for some years now, expecting not to have been great during COVID. There might have been a little bit of a tick back since then, but, realistically, have we got a renaissance of effectiveness insight? No. Absolutely not. And there are lots of reasons for that, which I'm sure we're gonna talk about. So I can be pretty confident that if we have turned the course in its corner, it's probably only the very, very beginnings, but that might prove to be wildly optimistic. I suspect we're not learning the lessons of ineffectiveness en masse. Some people are, but, you know, those tend to be, you know, blue chip companies, smart marketers, the ones who really know what they're doing in this game, whereas the mass don't, frankly, and we're making some really dumb mistakes out there. So I don't want to sound pessimistic. There are some positive... Very positive things going on in the market at the moment. But do I think, in general, effectiveness has turned a corner? I very much doubt it. I'd love to believe it, but it's going to take quite a lot of hard data to convince me that we really have sussed things and and are putting it right. So

Speaker 1 · 2:02

Well, one of the things that you said there that that interest me is that you said that there's there's a couple of things that have occurring that... That's positive. So what I'm gonna ask you is to give you one reason why you think we haven't quite turned that corner, and then the next thing is give me the positive things that you're seeing, the silver lining or the the light at the end of the tunnel.

Speaker 0 · 2:20

Well, the the... I mean, the two are related, really. I mean, the reason why I don't think we have turned the corner is because we're not really seeing it in the media patterns. I mean, there are some positive rays of light. I think the growth of connected TV, which is having, you know, a massive impact, and as it spreads into new markets, people are biting at it. You know, they really can't wait to get their hands on it because I think smart marketers know that they need TV, but they are inhibited from using it because of all of the data, you know, the kind of immediate data feedback that they haven't been able to get from it. So there are new technical developments in TV that are helping us at least put right some of the worst media wrongs. I think to be cheerful about is that with attention science, I think, really, really coming of age now, the the growth of a knowledge of it is is building all the time, certainly at the sophisticated end of marketing. I I don't come across many marketers these days, who are not, at least, to some degree, aware of it, and most of them are engaging with it in some way. They realize that they've been buying shit for years and that this is in part, you know, responsible for underperformance. And so, you know, with the aid of the data, that a explains, you know, what we mean when I say shit. What I mean is low attention platforms, which we just simply cannot drive long term effectiveness on. Once we understand that, we can begin to put it right. And of course, that in in part, I'm sure, is helping to feed the... I won't call it a feeding frenzy, but a real enthusiasm for connected TV in in markets as as as they as they roll out. That's a a positive side. You know, on the negative side, we've got still an obsession with short term effects. Businesses, you know, obsessively wedded to short term effects. And I don't, for a moment, criticize marketers. I think most smart marketers realize the problem. They know about balance of long and short, and they they they know they're not hitting the right sweet spots. But they've got superiors, colleagues, they've got CEOs, and CFOs who don't give a shit. They don't know about that. And, therefore, they are really obligated to use these performance marketing platforms and to put far too much money behind it. So, you know, on one hand, we... I think we are slowly educating the marketing world, at least from the top down. It's gradually growing. But it's not them that are the problem for effectiveness. It's really, non marketing areas of, managed general management. So the CEOs and the CFOs and and others that get involved in this. So there's a big job to be done there. The other thing that I think we really need to put right is just on the quality of the creative work because, you know, we've had twenty years now of thinking performance marketing, and an awful lot of marketers and an awful lot of creative people have become, you know, just kind of locked into a kind of creative style that is really about performance. It's not about building brands. There is obviously work to be done, work going on on that, but there's much, much bigger buy in, I think, needs to be achieved for the, requirements to improve creative because it's pretty, pretty grim, quite widespread, pretty grim.

Speaker 1 · 5:38

It's quite interesting. All those three points are are actually the sort of three main tenants of what we're gonna discuss today. And when I talk to clients, I ask them a very simple question. When CFOs and CEOs get involved in in media and marketing decisions, does marketing end up turning a bit shit? And, obviously, live on stage, they can't say yes, but privately, they know how damaging it is once those guys get involved because it turns into a cost discussion. Really, media and marketing is is is an investment decision, and I think we've we've lost sight of that a little bit. I'm gonna go on to the the split between brand and performance because I feel as though we almost need to move on from this discussion. Obviously, with your work, you have very clear indication of of where you should put your money. Most brands that I'm talking to today don't optimise to that ratio. They just don't. Right? They they are they are 80, 90, 70, if you like, in favour of performance. Do we just sit there and go, right. That's just it. We just have to deal with it. Has that has that sort of conversation ended in your view?

Speaker 0 · 6:41

Well, you know, I get this as well. I've spoken to so many people in so many events where they said, hey, Peter. This sounds like a really good idea, but you know what? We haven't got a hope of achieving it. So, you know, this I get all the time. So I don't kid myself for a moment, but just because the understanding that there is a sweet spot between brand and performance is kind of there, that we're any nearer to achieving it. I think we have to wait for for Connor Darwin, really. We have to wait for the survivor of the fittest here. There are great case studies. There are good brands that are achieving great growth through getting that sweet spot right. You know, I'm not saying they're not spending crazy on brand. They're just getting some kind of balance between the two. And generally speaking, again, lots of case study evidence of this as you migrate from the kind of lunacy of, say, twenty eighty brand brand performance, which so many brands are doing or worse. Mhmm. As you start to migrate towards a more balanced sweet spot, you start to see the results. So, you know, you don't necessarily have to go all the way there before you start to see some positive progress. So there's a learning curve to be made. We have to wait for for Darwinism to get to work here and just to see that the brands that are restoring growth, the businesses that are making margin out of their brands are the ones that are doing this. And, you know, that... There is evidence out there. There's more and more of these brands. So I think, you know, I think we we have to wait for that to to come good. And there's nothing like crisis for a for a business to make it realize that it's gotta change its act, and that that has been looming for years for, those who pursue too much performance marketing. We we all know that the wheels come off the machine if you do too much of it. So we have to wait for that too. I mean, pendulum... The pendulums do swing. I'm sure we will get to a point where if it's not too late and too many brands don't die, there will come a point where, people realize that, at least CEOs and CFOs realize that the machine is broke, that what they've been told about the power of performance and about about, you know, how buying impressions is simply a cost game, not a value game. You know, once they begin to realize that they've been completely misled, by the wisdom of of the marketplace, that things will improve. I mean, but how bad it's gotta get before that happens is not something that I particularly want to look at. But, anyway I share your optimism. But the problem is when I look at your chart, your your decline starts in 2,000 and, 2008.

Speaker 1 · 9:20

We're almost twenty years into this, and the examples are just racking up. Right? Yeah. The AA in The UK, Adidas just after that, and then Nike saw it and went, you know what? We'll do exactly the same thing. The the the repetition of mistakes in this industry are apps... They absolutely done found me. Right? The power of the other side of performance to convince these brands to do it must be outstanding. The one thing I wanna wanna ask you is, like, do you think this occurs because there's just a lack of education and training in the industry? And I'm hearing this a lot from clients that the quality of marketers coming through are,

Speaker 0 · 9:55

are lacking. Right? And, you know, these brands used to spend an awful lot of money on proper training, and perhaps that isn't occurring today. Do do you think that's a major issue within within the Certainly. I mean, the man who has a lot a lot of good data on this, of course, is Mark Ritson who, you know I saw that presentation. Yeah. Yeah. But, of course, he would say that, of course, because he has a, you know, a mini MBA program. But, you know, he has done the research, and Yeah. His views on the status of marketing training, particularly in The US, is is pretty grim. You know? I mean, it's it's not Under 50%? Not... Mhmm. Yeah. No. We know they're not they're not teaching the right kind of stuff, you know, in business schools where they where they even do teach it. So, you know, a lot of young masters coming into the business, I mean, really, all they can fall back on is their own very much digital native world kind of experience. And Yeah. You know, it is a very clouded view of what works. So, Mhmm. Yeah. Massive massive improvements in training clearly need to happen. If Mark Ritson, you know, achieves his business goals for the mini MBA, then we'll get... That'll that'll happen. I mean, he's making huge inroads, I think, already on this, general lack of trading. I like wishing him huge success because, god, it's necessary.

Speaker 1 · 11:10

Yeah. That that, particular report was done with Ipsos, I believe. It was a really interesting presentation I actually saw in camp myself. And another interesting presentation, which I saw actually last week, was Ehrenberg Bass. And what was interesting about it is that I think I saw them about fifteen years ago, and I was a proper fanboying out on the presentation. But what's so fascinating is that it's the same presentation that I saw probably fifteen years ago. So the the the key thing I wanna sort of illustrate here is that the theory just hasn't changed, has it? It's just it's just the media environment has changed. Is that is that the point where we wanna make it?

Speaker 0 · 11:46

It it... It's true that the fundamentals of effectiveness haven't changed. You know, the importance of re, you know, and and so on and so forth. There are some unuseful disagreements between sources between, for instance, Les and Me and Ehrenberg Bass on issues like price... Pricing power, which can confuse things. But by and large, those kind of fundamentals of the need to reach haven't changed. But, of course, the problem is that the Ehrenberg Bass model was really built in a legacy world where reach measured by, you know, exposure was was good enough. You know? If I get an impression on legacy media, whether it's TV or it, I kind of knew there was there was value that people would be watching it and into it, seeing it, and the market had settled on a kind of pretty reliable value for what that impression was. So money kinda chased impact in a much more reliable way. What we've had since then, of course, is a complete change in that. So, you know, we think we're buying reach. And, of course, the Ehrenberg Bass mantra, which is valid in a... As a kind of academic tool, has to be updated to the practical tool because it's not reach. Yeah. There is reach that achieves something, achieves what what Ehrenberg Bass wanted to achieve, which is mental availability. But we now know from the attention scientists, particularly the work, obviously, of Karen Nelson Field and an ex Ehrenberg Basser. You know? So she knows this shit. She knows all sides of this challenge. But the point she will tell you is that if you don't buy the right kind of reach, you ain't never gonna achieve mental availability because your attention levels are so low that you're not landing brand memories building long term memories. And that's the critical update, I think, to this kind of reach mantra that has to be taught, and it should be taught by Aaron Burr Bassett and everyone else who teaches it. I certainly do this. I talk about the importance of reach, and I see, but it's not reach at any cost. It's quality reach. It's attentive reach that you've gotta get. And if you ain't getting attentive reach, you ain't getting reach. So we've gotta do this... We've gotta join this up somehow. And, you know, these schisms between Aerobass and attention science, it really doesn't help. It all needs to get joined up because otherwise, we're not going to prevail on the world of business and marketing to be buying the right kind of reach in particular and, you know, and generally following the rules rules for growth. And that's probably the most the most important one that that we need to think about.

Speaker 1 · 14:26

Yeah. No. You you you make a very good point there. And it's, obviously all impressions are not created equal. And and what we have in this industry is unlimited impressions. Right? And you've got a huge cost press... Pressure on all media ecosystems, and it's having an impact across many different businesses that offer incredible ad platforms and some, in my view, that don't. And then what happens is that the CFOs and CEOs get involved. And this is the one question I get from nearly every marketer is that they're involved. It becomes about the data that supports the the investment. It becomes about price, and they shift in one direction. And they don't they don't know how to convince them to shift back. What's the bit of advice you can give to those marketers that need to convince C suite to focus on other aspects? We're talking about not just attention, but we're talking about trust. We're talking about impact.

Speaker 0 · 15:18

Absolutely. Well, yeah, you've gotta present the evidence, haven't you? And I try and do that. You know, there's plenty of evidence in the data I work with that says that the trust building capabilities of different platforms are radically different. As it happens, these things do align. The same platforms that are good at building trust tend to be quite good at building attention as well, creating attention. So they tend to all lead you in the same direction to to to some degree anyway. I mean, it's not perfect alignment. So you just got to keep bringing the data, presenting the data to... Particularly to CFOs. Because if you don't give them a value argument, then, of course, they're gonna buy on price. You know, if you can see the price differences, but you don't know the quality differences, understood the importance of the quality differences, that buy may look cheap, but you know what? It's not gonna strengthen your brand. It's not gonna drive long term results. And more importantly, it's not gonna create trust or any of the other virtues that brands need to particularly. So we need this data collected. We need it presented to CFOs particularly, and we need to find some way of getting this on the... I don't know, on the agenda of of of finance training, courses. There needs to be a big outreach, I think, from personally people like like Mark Ritson and others and academics generally to say, look, it's it's the CFOs in the making that need to hear all of this. Let's get to business schools. Let's try and get this on the agenda of business schools so that tomorrow's business leaders are more broadly acquainted with the realities of marketing. Because they, of course, they take meetings with the big digital companies. You know? They they hear all of that. They only hear half the story. They hear about pricing. They hear about their kind of view of reach and the impressions you can get. Yeah. But you've got to see the other side of the story. But if you don't give them the evidence, you know, why should a CFO do anything other than follow low prices? But, you know, it's it's... For me, one of the eye popping moments was to... You've seen this chart, Justin. I think when you look at what you buy if you buy low CPMs in The UK market, and it leads you relentlessly to social media. But if you say, no. That's not what I think we should be buying. We're not gonna buy CPMs. We're gonna buy attentive cost per thousand. So how much does it cost us to buy a thousand seconds of attention or whatever our unit is? And when you do that, the hierarchy is more or less completely reversed. Suddenly, social looks damn expensive, and suddenly, all of the legacy media that have been so derided by the big digital players, with the exception of Amazon, like TV, suddenly start to look incredibly good value. So, you know, you've you've got to. Now that, of course, is based on brand building power. When you think about performance, that that will be much less true. I mean, there will still be a significant element of that in it. But if you're trying to buy simple performance, then you can do that with lower attention. You still need a bit more than I think you're gonna get from a typical social platform. But... So you've got to win all these arguments simultaneously. The importance of brand, the importance of attention to building brand, the importance of other context strengths of certain media to building brand like trust, you know. Is this an environment that is full of fake news and corrosive stuff and so forth? So you've got to build the commercial value of all of those, and the whole argument has to be one together. But but if a CFO is still saying, well, this brand thing is an expensive nonsense. I'm not interested in that. So what's the point of all of this? You've got to join this argument up to win it, I think.

Speaker 1 · 19:06

Yeah. You're right. And and when you mentioned that that that you needed evidence and perhaps there's been a lack of evidence, what I find surprising, particularly around this attention stuff, is a lot of the research that you're talking about with with Karen and others came out 2015, 2016. And then in 2022, so we're talking six years later, Karen revealed that 85% of the ads that we buy don't even reach the attention threshold, which is less than 2%. And then you came out with a slide. This is the one that always shocks me is that the... You say that the the the evidence is irrefusable. Right. High attention media delivers better results in the short term and long term. And even for performance related brands, so smaller brands, high attention is actually more important. Yeah. It's when you see that slide that 70% of the spend is going towards lower attention over higher attention. So the data is there. We're talking... We're ten years into this, and we're still buying lower attention crappy media. So what do you need to do about it? Like, we've got the data. So what what else is there to do? Or or is this just is this just how long it takes in the industry to fix?

Speaker 0 · 20:09

Well, it is a supertanker, of course. The industry is a supertanker? I mean, yeah, it certainly is. For for big smart brands, I think the picture isn't as bad as I did. Most big smart brands are not spending 70% on performance. They will be doing better than that. That's not that's not to say that that there isn't still an issue. But I think we just have to start cherishing, sharing, you know, the data from the big blue chip marketing organizations that are getting it right. And, of course, from time to time, there there are wobbles as we've seen. Adidas, Nike, all of these. Regularly, we see financial services businesses where some new young hotshot comes along and says, building brands in financial services is damn hard work. It's a waste of money. Let's just put it all into digital and go performance. And for six to twelve months, it's probably starts to look pretty seductive because they've got all the momentum of the brand investment of the path, but you're putting it all into aggressive performance marketing. It's probably not gonna do too badly. So it probably looks fine for six to twelve months, but it's... You gotta wait for the wheels to fall off. And that seems to happen time and time again. So these these are... All these organizations are capable of being misled by, you know, hotshots who come in and say, I could save you a ton of money, and we could supercharge the efficiency of our spend. They can only do it for a short period of time. It's not sustainable. That's that's the issue here. But by then, of course, they've moved on, and they'll go do it someplace else. And, you know

Speaker 1 · 21:43

Yeah. It's interesting. Those hotshots those hotshots that you're referring to is, I like to call them management consultants. They're usually they're usually part of the problem. Well, some... Yes. Some of them probably are. They're not not all... I don't think they're all that. But, yes. Yes. No. And you... And you're talking about sometimes a wobble. It's funny that you describe Adidas and Nike as more bubbles. When you put that actually together of what they've destroyed, it's... We're we're talking close to about a 100,000,000,000 of of value. So, I mean, that's not a wobble. That's a colossal fuck up in my opinion. The the other... It's extraordinary. Isn't it? One of the other things that we talk about with trust is that you you were saying to me, and maybe you can illustrate this a bit better, is that trust isn't just about the media environment that you you advertise in or you put your brands around. There is a there's a rub off effect to the more trusted environments to, to the advertisers that are that are in it. But trust is actually a major component of effectiveness from PR, comms, other aspects. What... Why has trust, like, shot up, if you like?

Speaker 0 · 22:43

It's And become more It's a bit... It's a really interesting question. I mean, all all I can do is hypothesize. I mean, you'd have to speak to other people who who kinda track these things, the edelmans of this world, I guess. But Yeah. The obvious hypothesis is that, consumers ain't stupid. They know that most of the news, data, stuff that they're fed, particularly on social these days, is just frankly not real... Not true. We we know that's the We have really good data to illustrate that. The platforms that are are better, have better governance and are regulated are more trusted. That's just fact, isn't it? Yeah. And the recent recent years, of course, fact checking, that was beginning beginning to be imposed on these big platforms, has, of course, gone out the window. So all of that Mhmm. Checking, kind of pressure is gone. It's now free free house, open house for loony content. Anyone who wants to say anything can can do a good way. And consumers aren't stupid. They know this. They can see that they increasingly can't believe what what they're reading, what they're seeing. So in that context, inevitably, Marshall McLuhan in the nineteen sixties, I mean, a Canadian, if I haven't say, he must be smart. He wrote, you know, the medium is the message. The environment in which your ads appear inevitably shapes the response to those to those ads, and that has always been true. We've known media planners, media buyers always paid a premium for good environments. You know, that's why, you know, the front news pages of of newspapers, magazines often used to be clearly sought after because those... That was where the news with Gravitas sat, you know, and and that was good for advertisers. It showed it showed importance, and it showed truth, and it showed stature in the advertiser. Now we do exactly the opposite. We hide our ads away from that kind of content. Instead, we put it away increasingly in kind of vacuous, untruthful kind of untruthful kind of environments where anything goes. The reality is if people know that your ad is surrounded by untruths, it's not gonna help the ad achieve what it needs to. It's a very simple piece of psychology, really, and it's more true now, I would argue, than it than it ever has been. So I suspect that's why we've seen it become more important over the years. It used used to be relatively unimportant twenty, twenty five years ago now, but now it's clearly is important. And, you know, companies again aren't aren't aftermarket research they do tells them that trust is a really important issue for choice of brands and for commitment to brands, and and they're very keen to build it. They wouldn't they wouldn't be obsessed with with with trust if it wasn't their market research telling them that. So, you know, it... That is the truth of it.

Speaker 1 · 25:34

Mhmm. Yeah. It's interesting. Couple of good data points there to support what you're saying. In 2,002, newspapers in The US were the biggest media sellers in the country. Isn't that crazy? It's 2002, so it's only just over twenty years ago. Obviously, that market has has changed quite dramatically. And then when you look at your effectiveness stuff and then you align it with the rise of performance media and investment into these channels that often are cheaper, you can see that we're we're creating a lot of media and a lot of advertising that basically is less impactful. So there's a lot of data to support what you're saying. You mentioned at the beginning about the creative aspect, and, I was very lucky to see you present with Adam Morgan. And you've you've managed to actually put a price on the cost of being dull.

Speaker 0 · 26:16

Cost of dull. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's great. So you're It was a it was a really interesting exercise, and I have to say, this is Adam's Adam's idea. But with the IPA data, we were able to do it for an average brand in an average category in The UK marketplace. And and the number was quite astonishing. So, you know, what we found... What was the number? Well, the the number represents the extra budget a brand that runs bottom quartile interesting advertising would have to find to match the in market effectiveness of, again, an average band that was running top quartile most interesting advertising. And it's about £10,000,000 per annum. Now if you think about that in The US marketplace, it's gonna be at least six, seven, eight times the the amount. So these these are big sums of money, and we kinda gross this up to look at the aggregate amounts wasted in markets. And we're talking GDP of Greece was finding of system one. That is the amount of money US advertisers essentially waste on dull advertising. These are vast, vast, vast numbers of money, billions and billions of dollars. So, yeah, it's it's a big problem.

Speaker 1 · 27:25

Yeah. Huge problem. What is dull? Just out of interest, like, when you when you think about this, what's what's interesting and what's dull? Yeah. So dull is essentially where it is factual

Speaker 0 · 27:35

and rational, and and it... What it is trying to do is to inform you of some reason. Now there's there's there's nothing wrong with informing people, but you have to do it in a way that engages and entertains them. Otherwise, the facts just don't linger in people's minds. It becomes essentially performance advertising. And this is what what I'm saying earlier on. You know, creativity has been led by the performance marketers. If you're trying to close a sale, bottom bottom of funnel performance marketing, you can assume that the people who are seeing your ad are interested in the buy. They've already showed that they're searching for the product you've got to sell. All you have to do is say, look, you know, we only cost $2.50 an extra extra bell and whistle this month if you make the purchase. You can very quickly and very easy with some simple facts nudge them over the line. But if it's top of funnel, if we're talking about people who are, you know, not yet in the market to buy, they're not looking to buy at the moment, to get them to take on board what you want to tell them about your product, and it could well be it's a product demo. Some of the most effective and memorable ads are often product demos. They're showing you something kind of literal about the product. But the point about those kind of ads is they are done in a very entertaining way, often funny, very memorable. We take on board the piece of information that will cue our choice later on, but it's done in a way that means we just love remembering it. Because every time we remember it, it brings back those tickles our tickles our memory buds, as it were, with memories of that lovely ad. So that is what we have lost. So dull is where I just tell you the facts. I'm not gonna try and gloss them. I'm not gonna try and dress them. I'm just gonna give them to you because that's all I'm capable of doing. Whereas non dull is about how do we make that part of a much, much more engaging, interesting, and emotional message. And you have to do that because you have to make it noticeable. You have to make it memorable, and you have to make it, you know, just kind of persuasive. People Mhmm. People are persuaded more powerfully that way. So Yeah. It remains vitally important. And, again, it's part of this circular picture of decline that we've seen in effectiveness that we are doing far too much dull advertising.

Speaker 1 · 29:54

Yeah. It's just a lot harder to do, right, to provide that emotional connection, and it's probably why we default to to what's easiest.

Speaker 0 · 30:01

It is more difficult. It requires talented creative people with great ideas. You know the craft. And Mhmm. Again, in a world where everything is being just reduced to the cheapest possible level, You know, you're ending up with with... Without that talent that can do that.

Speaker 1 · 30:18

Yeah. Do you know it tie... It ties into the attention story that you're saying as well because usually emotive creative that's interesting takes actually time to consume. There's not much you can do in a in a second spot. And and as an Absolutely. Yeah. The worry is we're destroying those industries that actually create those sort of bigger canvases, if you like, to create that emotive... Emotional connection. In fact, this is one of the big worries is that the the business models of these companies, I'm talking about television, in a pure ad sense, is actually, like, really heavily challenged to provide those opportunities for advertisers. So I always say to advertisers, it's incumbent on you guys in the markets that you're in to do whatever you can to support that industry because it's not only good to the local media, economy to have choice, but it's also really fucking good for your brands to sell your products. That's the that's that's the point. That's why I think they should be way more supportive. I just got a quick question on this is... So you can just yes, no, if you want. Do you think the industry overly obsesses with media at this... At the expense of focusing on building this great creative that you speak of?

Speaker 0 · 31:22

Yes and no. Yes. It is over obsessed with media, but you need to fix the media problem before you can fix the creative problem. What we do know is serving great creative on a shit platform is just a waste of everybody's time and effort. You know, if you really want to win as a marketer and a business, you've gotta serve great creative on great high attention platforms. So I'm, you know, very much influenced by my my my friends, you know, at Amplified Intelligence and Lumen, who say you gotta fix the media problem first. So, you know, so in that sense, they're not over obsessing with it, but you... We got obsessed with both these creative and media attentive power.

Speaker 1 · 32:01

Yeah. It's interesting because the the the first line about this, which is years old, is that it doesn't matter. If you're putting shit down the pipe, it doesn't matter which pipe. But, actually, what you're saying now is even good stuff down the wrong pipe can... Will have the same outcome as that. So we... We've gotta actually talk about the pipes a little bit more.

Speaker 0 · 32:20

Absolutely. No. We absolutely do. No. Indeed. Indeed. But, you know, at the end of the day, let's just remember quality is worth paying for, whether it's media or creative. It... You know, quality is worth paying for.

Speaker 1 · 32:33

So can I talk about mass reach? Because a lot of this relies on on, carpet bombing categories with this emotive, good advertising. I think... Do you think the industry has sort of lost sight on that? Mass reach is quite hard to sell, because we're we're so we're so good at this ability to be precise and to target. Do you think mass reach is a little unfashionable?

Speaker 0 · 32:56

Well, it it certainly is unfashionable despite despite the work of Ermaud Bass to remind us all that if you've got a mass market brand, you need mass reach. I mean, obviously, you know, it's it's... Depends on the category. By and large, most mass market brands need mass reach. You know, quality reach in the ways that we've been talking about. But, yeah. No. I mean, I think I think it it it remains extremely important. But, yeah, you're right. Everybody seems that's inefficient. Part of the value of building a brand is not that just you're building it in a one to one sense, but you're you're ensuring that that potential buyer understands that their peer group, their social network, everyone around them is also holding the same values and the same enthusiasm for that brand. And and that is particularly, of course, doubly important if we are trying to reinforce the pricing power of that brand. Because generally speaking, brands that are perceived to be widely valued by, you know, not just yourself, but everyone around you, are brands that people are prepared to pay a little bit more for, and that's vitally important. So, You know, waste is good. Waste is good because it's not actually waste. It's only waste in the sense that, you know, 90% of the people getting that message aren't going to buy right now. But they are gonna buy one day. If you've really been lousy in your media buying, they will buy one day. And if you've got good advertising, they will remember that message. That message will influence their purchasing and influence it in two ways, make it more likely and, b, make it more profitable for you. So mastery, absolutely vital, should not be sneered at, by the smart arses of performance marketing who know nothing about brands by and large.

Speaker 1 · 34:51

So so I wanna just end on a couple of recent sort of developments, I guess, in the industry. When you look at Unilever and Coke, right, TV just sometimes appears not as fashionable as the new area, which is creators. Right? They were all over Cannes. They're influencer marketing. We're really going into the influencer marketing area. I think Unilever said that they're now a social first company rather than a broadcast first company. Coke are doing a very similar thing. They're switching a tremendous amount of money from television to influencers and social. How do you feel about that? Do you think that's a good idea? Do you think that's gonna work out for these brands?

Speaker 0 · 35:26

Well, first of all, I mean, if you're talking about shifting money from social advertising to influencers, I would probably say that is quite a good idea. But if you're talking about moving money from TV to influencers, that seems to me to be crazy. Why shift it from a proven medium to a highly experimental and quite undisciplined world? So it's still a bit wild west that the bubble does seem to be beginning to burst a little bit, you know, but the problem with influence is... I was initially very skeptical, but I do accept that, you know, if you can get a good influencer, on the case, you can achieve stuff, particularly on social, that you'll never achieve in any other way. So it it has a value to me. The problem of always is how do you scale quality in creator, content? How do you scale it? Because for every good creator influencer out there, there's a ton of not so good ones. And and also what you're essentially buying is you're buying their follow-up, world, aren't you, which is based on content they've produced in the past. It's got nothing to do with commercial messages. You've got to tread really carefully as an advert... As an advertiser because you're in danger of killing the goose that laid the golden head. You've got this great creator who has done great wacky content, which has got him a huge following or her a huge following, and then suddenly you want them to help you sell washing powder. Now it... It's always gonna be challenging, isn't it? You've gotta tread carefully, and I think the ability to scale that is is really difficult. And I think it'd make a good contribution, a good new tool. It's a good way of using social as a brand building tool in my book. But does it really pass the mass market test? Well, that's that's the challenge these guys are all gonna face. You know? Can you really replace mass market, mass reach media with high attention levels with a pretty random loose knit bunch of creators? Because no one creator is probably gonna give you the reach you need. You're gonna have to stitch together a basket of dozens of these people. But, no, thousands. You're talking Thousands. Right. Absolutely. Yeah. Thousands. Sorry. You're absolutely right. I shouldn't particularly if you're talking about Coca Cola. Many thousands. A, how do you discipline that? And and, B, how does it all work together? You know, how does... How is there a coherent, consistent brand at the end of all of that? It's pretty difficult. It's gonna be pretty difficult to achieve that. And if you can achieve it for a year, how can you achieve it for multiple years? I don't know. It's unproven, and I would be pretty nervous about putting all my eggs in that basket in one hell of a rush. But

Speaker 1 · 38:06

Mhmm. Someone's got to experiment. Someone's got to experiment. Yeah. No. I just think that we're going into it probably a little bit too deep because I think one thing that I've been talking to a lot of clients about is whether you can actually build your brand in these environments. Most of them say that you can't. They recognize it. It's more of a commerce chat, channel. And and I think in that way, it can be really effective, but it's just overdue.

Speaker 0 · 38:26

It might be possible, but it's not easy. I'm... To imagine it's it's straightforward. I mean, brands are built by influencers. You know? I mean, it's... I mean, which... Whether you can do it at a huge scale, global scale, that's a much, much bigger challenge than launching a new fashion or fragrance brand or make brand, which, clearly, you can do in that route. But but it's... Can you scale it? Can you keep it going? Can you maintain the momentum? And that is where I'm much more skeptical, but we'll see. But, personally, if I was either of those two big companies that you mentioned, I would be experimenting much more gingerly than they are, frankly. I'd take one or two brands and put a chunk of the budget, but not all of it, and see what I learned. I would test and learn the hell out of it before I started making big public announcements that this was the future of our brand building. I just think that's

Speaker 1 · 39:29

Yeah. It's just the weather. It's just where the industry is. It sounds fashionable, and I'm sure you... Wall Street's Sounds great, doesn't it? Sounds like yours. I'm great. Super switched on in a yacht. It does.... Cutting edge in marketing. Well,

Speaker 0 · 39:41

people have fallen on on their faces before, and this may well happen here. We'll see. We'll see. Well, it's interesting,

Speaker 1 · 39:48

way to close out on it. I think we've covered a lot there that the the theory hasn't changed. The media market has, and effectiveness is is where it is, and we can hope that maybe it will uptick. I'm I'm looking forward to that 2026 data on that. Focus on creativity and focus on... Let's not look at cost, let's look at the other aspects that goes into your media spend. As you've said, there's, attention, there's other quality metrics around trust, and and I'd I'd throw transparency in there too, so you know that you're actually hitting humans. So Peter, this has been fascinating as always. Thank you very much for your time.

The Newsletter

Never miss an episode

A short note in your inbox when a new episode or piece lands — the argument, the data and where to find it. No noise.

Double opt-in — we’ll email you to confirm. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.